Hawaii Catholic Herald

Newspaper of the Diocese of Honolulu

  • Home
  • Local
    • Local News
    • Official Notices
    • Obituary
    • Bishop Silva
    • Catholic Schools
    • Office for Social Ministry
  • US/World
  • Columns
    • Mary Adamski
    • Msgr. Owen F. Campion
    • Christina Capecchi
    • Viriditas
  • Features
    • Quiz
    • Heralding Back
    • Photo
    • Pope Francis
    • Manaolana
      • Catechism Corner
      • Helpful Hints
      • Sidebar
      • Stories & Columns
  • Archive
  • Subscribe
  • Advertise
  • Podcast
  • Donate
  • Contact

Standing strong

11/18/2026 by Hawaii Catholic Herald

Vandalism of a beloved Kalapana church ‘cannot destroy our faith’

Father John Molina, pastor of Sacred Heart Church in Pahoa, celebrated Mass Nov. 6 at Star of the Sea Church in Kalapana, which was vandalized last month. (Lisa Dahm / Hawaii Catholic Herald)

By Lisa Dahm

Hawaii Catholic Herald

On a quiet road off Highway 130, Star of the Sea Painted Church in Kalapana offers its community, and worldwide visitors, a serene place to meditate on the masterpieces left behind by talented artists long ago.

The decommissioned Catholic church was vandalized last month by a suspect who broke statues and windows (a 58-year-old area resident was arrested) — but that did not break a resilient group of artists and community members. In fact, it inspired them to rally together and support the little church that could and definitely does.

At First Friday Mass Nov. 6 with Father John Molina, pastor of Sacred Heart Church in Pahoa, a faithful group of about a dozen people filled Star of the Sea, unruffled by the remnants of the event not even two weeks earlier.

“They may destroy everything material, but they cannot destroy our faith,” Father Molina said. “They cannot take away the love we have. I think it’s a wonderful meditation for each one of us — that we don’t attach ourselves to the material things.”

One of the two church caretakers, Pancho Aldana, discovered the smashed statues and windows on Oct. 21. The man charged for the vandalism at the church was arrested on Oct. 23, according to a Hawaii Police Department media release.

The six damaged statues included those of Jesus, Mary, St. Joseph with baby Jesus, St. Christopher and two angels, which Father Molina said were most likely from Belgium and were almost a century old. The Marian statue was broken into more than 200 pieces, some merely dust, according to Aldana.

Rosanna Kanoa, the other caretaker whose business is located directly across the street from the church, said the total loss amount was about $50,000, with the majority of the cost going to the stained-glass windows of St. Damien de Veuster and St. Marianne Cope, and a front window that was made of etched glass.

The now-decommissioned church sits on a road off Highway 130 after it was relocated in the 1990s to save it from lava flows. (Lisa Dahm / Hawaii Catholic Herald)

Saved from lava

In 1930, Sacred Hearts Father Evarist Gielen built Star of the Sea about 10 miles inland from Kalapana as a mission of Sacred Heart Church in Pahoa, according to an earlier Hawaii Catholic Herald story.

Father Gielen painted the church interior with scriptural scenes. Other visitors contributed their artistic touches to the church in the 1960s and 1970s.

In the 1990s, Kalapana was overrun by lava for six months. Members of the Kalapana Ohana Association rescued the painted church from lava flows and transported it to safety by flatbed truck. The Diocese of Honolulu decommissioned the church at that time, and it now resides on state-owned land.

While members of the Kalapana Ohana are long gone, Kanoa and Aldana have been stewarding the property for more than 25 years. They take turns opening the church and closing it at the end of the day so visitors can spend time there. Kanoa pays the building’s insurance and for an onsite portable restroom on her own and from any donations that visitors leave in the metal box.

Kanoa also offers the church for community events and trainings organized by Red Road Resilience Network, a local nonprofit organization that brings the community together and offers emergency care through grants when needed.

A table holding pieces of a shattered statue is set up beneath a stained-glass window at Star of the Sea Painted Church in Kalapana. (Courtesy Roseanna Kanoa)

Community, artists rally

Providentially, the weekend before the vandalism, Red Road Resilience Network had used the church to distribute gift cards through United Way to 130 people who were affected by flooding from this summer’s spate of damaging hurricanes.

Since neither Kanoa nor Aldana have social media pages, Red Road’s Kristen McCormack offered to post their need on the network’s social media pages and help them with a fundraiser. The call immediately drew local Hawaii island artists to assist.

McCormack — who serves as event organizer, outreach program director and volunteer coordinator for Red Road — said $1,600 was raised within the first two days.

“The Star of the Sea Church is a really beloved part of our whole community,” McCormack said. “It’s (one of) the last pieces of old Kalapana.”

“I think the most beautiful part of a story is actually the artists who have just so generously shown up,” McCormack said. “Their generosity is inspiring.”

A 94-year-old artist named George Capron has been leading the repair of the angels and all the sculptures. An expert in art restoration with 60 years of experience in the field, Capron now lives in a veterans’ retirement home. Volunteers have been coordinating rides to transport him to the church.

“He’s extraordinarily skillful, and he’s touched the hearts of everybody who gets to work with him,” McCormack said. “They love to talk story and hear his amazing experience just in life.”

McCormack said other contributing artists include Ken Charon, Jeffrey von Mayer, stained-glass artist Roger Moses and Angie Cahill.

“Angie Cahill is helping Roger with (the) stained glass,” McCormack said. “She collected the broken glass from the first etched stained glass to make pendants as a part of a fundraiser so that people can have a part of the Painted Church with them.”

“Who would have known that we have the most amazing expert art restoration people living within 20 miles,” McCormack added.

Nainoa Rosehill, a well-regarded Hawaiian artist, grew up in Kalapana. Historic Hawaiian churches, particularly Star of the Sea, have inspired much of his art. He has offered to assist with an upcoming fundraiser and to give an exhibition of his work.

“He has always dreamed of having his hand in the tending of Star of the Sea,” McCormack said. “He was so touched.”

Support the restoration

In December, Red Road Resilience Network will hold a fundraiser for Star of the Sea Church, sharing the history of the church and old Kalapana, and also host a candlelit concert.

“Part of the story of this church is it’s got layers of love infused into it throughout the decades,” McCormack said. “So, this is the start of a new layer. I’m very excited.”

To donate to the church restoration, visit the Red Road Restoration Network donation page at https://www.zeffy.com/en-US/donation-form/donate-to-help-restore-the-historic-star-of-the-sea-painted-church.

Filed Under: Features, Local News Tagged With: Hawaii Island, Kalapana, Red Road Resilience Network, Star of the Sea Painted Church, vandalism

Catholic News Service

Make a donation

About us

The Hawaii Catholic Herald is published every other Friday. It is mailed to individual households and has a statewide circulation of about 17,000. SUBSCRIBE

Blog: “Stories behind the Stories”

Copyright © 2026 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in